Don’t Vote for a California Governor

This Fox and Hounds Daily offers a very interesting take on the California gubernatorial race.

Is ‘None of the Above’ the Smart Choice in the Governor’s Race?

Joe Mathews's picture

By Joe Mathews Journalist and Irvine senior fellow at the New America Foundation Fri, February 26th, 2010

If you think California governing system is badly broken, how should you vote in the governor’s race?

The likely nominees of each party, Jerry Brown and Meg Whitman, haven’t even bothered to offer an answer. (And for the record, Steve Poizner, despite being more specific about his policies than his rivals, has dodged this big question too).

Neither has spoken at any length about the state’s deep structural and constitutional problems, much less committed to addressing them.

At best, a vote for either Brown or Whitman is a wild guess. At worst, a vote for either is a waste of time. Without a mandate for broader change, the next governor, whether it’s Brown or Whitman, will be lucky to muddle through four years with more of the budget gimmicks and debt we’ve used for too long in California.

Is there a better option?

Well, leaving the ballot blank might be the better option.

A non-vote in the governor’s race isn’t a cop out. It’s a choice. In California, a “none of the above” vote has real weight.

How’s that? Because under the rules of California’s direct democracy, a non-vote for governor matters.

The qualification standards for initiatives and referendums are based on percentages of the number of votes cast for governor in the most recent election.

Thus, if fewer votes are cast in a governor’s race, it will take fewer signatures to qualify an initiative or referendum for the following four years. With lower signature requirements, the cost of qualifying initiatives drops.

So if you’re an advocate of a constitutional convention or some of the reforms offered by California Forward, you could give a boost to those efforts by not casting a vote in the governor’s race. Effectively, your non-vote would make it easier for those reformers – or others – to qualify their measures in the future. This could be an important boost for reformers, who have been unable to raise the big money needed to qualify measures this year.

Here’s a suggestion: someone in those reform movements should start making this point, and launch a campaign for “none of the above” in the governor’s race. Such an effort, if cleverly conceived, would be a lot cheaper than qualifying good government initiatives.

And if “none of the above” gained any steam, it could have more than just the long-term effect of making future reforms easier to qualify.

It might force Brown and Whitman to stop hiding the ball and start addressing the concerns of reform-minded voters right now.

Scott Brown May Be the First Independent

Coming Together for the Good of America 

You have to have a really tough skin to participate in politics.  One day you are loved and the next day you might be a turn coat.  Scott Brown knew this when he ran for senator from Massachusetts.  In recent days he has been the darling of the loosely knit Tea Party group.  That group is mostly a conservative, White, Anglo Saxon, Christian movement that has no specific leaders but has become the darling of American conservatives. 

Conservative talk show hosts like Rush Limbaugh, Sean Hannity, and Glenn Beck have been delighted with the thought that Republicans can win in liberal states like Massachusetts. 

Could it be that Scott Brown is a “Progressive Republican” as Beck suggests?  Perhaps Brown is Republican in the mold of Everett Dirksen or Ben Franklin.  Maybe Brown might lead a revolution to moderation and compromise.  What will those fringe talk show hosts say when most of us support coming together for the good of America? 

A Growing Movement of Independents

I am an Independent.  I belong to no political party.  I do miss the camaraderie that is part of the political parties.  I like being part of a group or club.  But “To thine own self be true.” is also part of my blood.  Apparently it is the stronger part.

I have heard that about 35% of registered voters are Democrats and about 25% are Republicans.  That means there are more Independents than the membership of either political party.  The numbers are now starting to include some talk show hosts.  The latest is Michael Smerconish who now says he has “exited the Republican Party after 30 years of active membership.”

It is doubtful that a third party will emerge to govern this nation.  None have successfully developed in the past.  Most likely both Republicans and Democrats will move to the political center and more Americans will vote for the candidate rather than the party.  That is a situation that will breed compromise.  That was the lesson from the nation’s founding fathers.

A Message to Iran

Everything points to American and Israeli preparation for a possible attack on Iran before that nation obtains the capability to produce nuclear bomb.  David Ignatius, of The Washington Post, stated on the Chris Matthews Show that the United States is on a fast track to the development a super bomb that could penetrate underground facilities.  Israel has unveiled a new drone fleet that can reach Iran.

Just a few days ago the New York Times published an editorial titled “Time’s up for talking with Iran.”  An edited version of that editorial was printed in the Toronto Star.  Clearly the U.S. government is making every effort to send a message to Iran.  That edited editorial appears below.  

Over the last four years, the United Nations Security Council has repeatedly demanded that Iran stop producing nuclear fuel. Iran is still churning out enriched uranium and has now told United Nations inspectors that it is raising the level of enrichment – moving slightly closer to bomb-grade quality.

Enough is enough. Iran needs to understand that its nuclear ambition comes with a very high cost.

President Barack Obama said on Tuesday that the United States and its allies are “moving along fairly quickly” on a new sanctions resolution. He also said it would take several weeks to draft a proposal. That is not reassuring. Once a resolution is written, the negotiating process typically drags on for weeks, if not months.

Iran is in such economic and political turmoil that its government may be more vulnerable to outside pressure. Security forces have expanded a crackdown on the political opposition, arresting hundreds of people ahead of Thursday’s anniversary of the Iranian revolution.

American officials say they are eager to impose sanctions that would inflict maximum damage on the Islamic Revolutionary Guards Corps, which runs the nuclear program and a large chunk of the Iranian economy.

The plan, as we understand it, is to block their banking, their shipping, their insurance. American officials also say they want to minimize the additional suffering of the Iranian people. That makes sense to us, although squaring the circle won’t be easy.

If the Security Council is to move ahead with sanctions that bite, Washington and its allies are going to have to step up the pressure on Russia and China – Iran’s two enablers, both with a veto – to go along.

Russia has signaled support for another resolution. If history is any guide, we fear Russia will sharply whittle down the impact. China, eager to buy ever more oil from Iran, is an even bigger obstacle. China needs to understand that ensuring reliable oil supplies would become a lot harder if the Middle East is roiled by a nuclear-armed Iran.

The more the Security Council temporizes, compromises and weakens these resolutions, the more defiant and ambitious Iran becomes. If the Security Council can’t act swiftly, or decisively, the United States and its allies will have to come up with their own tough sanctions. They should be making a backup plan right now.

This is an edited version of an editorial that appeared this week in the New York Times and was printed in the Toronto Star

Isn’t this all about sending a message to Iran?

If There is No Will There is No Way

I was an avid supporter of a California constitutional convention to bring sanity to this state. Such an effort requires significant financial backing. Unfortunately not enough people were willing to come to the aid of this endeavor. The Los Angeles Times editorial for this day says what I have been telling everyone. No one running for governor can change our dysfunctional government. Can California Forward accomplish the necessary changes we need?  I am dubious.  Below is the first paragraph from the Times editorial. It summarizes the situation.

Yes We Can!

The party of “no” provides no solutions to America’s problems. Mike Pence, congressman from Indiana, appeared at the CPAC (Conservative Political Action Conference) conference in Washington D.C. where he said, “Sometimes no is just what this town needs to hear. When it comes to more borrowing, the answer is no. When it comes to more spending, the answer is no. When it comes to more bailouts, the answer is no.”   We need the party of “yes we can.”

It’s all about compromise.  Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger and Gov. Edward Rendell appearing on This Week today displayed that kind of behavior.  Of course both political parties have to step up to the plate to make this happen.  If too many moderate congress people decide drop out then we will have many years of gridlock.

Tiger Woods is Pathetic

Where was Elin?  Perhaps she was sitting with Jenny  Sanford.

Professional athletes may love the games they play but the money is the motivating factor.  Reading a sorry explanation for bad behavior proves just one thing.  The reader can read.  Tiger Woods had made the golf profession very profitable for the television networks and other professional players.  Just because he is seen by a new Buick are in an Accenture commercial does not motivate me to buy the product.  These multimillionaire athletes just want to continue making the bug bucks.  Clearly we pay to watch them play.  Their personal lives have nothing to do with their athletic abilities. 

Today’s presentation by Tiger Woods was pathetic.  It did provide a one hour Larry King Live show and lots of talk for shows looking to entertain us.

February 20. 2010: This Toronto Star commentary really says it all.

Image

Kathy Battaglia of Tiger Woods Enterprises, below left, Tiger Woods’ mother Kultida Woods and Amy Reynolds, of Nike, listen as Woods makes a statement Feb. 19, 2010 at PGA Tour headquarters in Ponte Vedra Beach, Fla. 

JOE SKIPPER/REUTERS 

By Rosie DiManno, Toronto Star Columnist

VANCOUVER-Why is this man telling me these things? 

We’ve barely ever even met. He shouldn’t be speaking so to a stranger. 

And I don’t believe hardly a word of it either. My mother didn’t raise a dope. Who’s he trying to dupe? 

Like that part about not getting to play by different rules than other people. Of course he gets to play by different rules. That’s one privilege enjoyed by famous people, sometime even when they break the law, although this fellow committed no criminal offence. He may have trashed the vows of marriage, as most people at least superficially accept them, but surely that’s a matter between husband and wife, unless the betrayed spouse is demanding a public mea culpa. 

He’s in the dog house where adulterous hounds often end up except, in his case, it’s a fancier pad with a big tab daily room rate and custodians of the joint have pathologized the libido to the extent of branding such behaviour an addiction, no doubt with a 12-step self-help program to follow before graduating. 

“Hello, my name is Tiger and I haven’t cheated on my wife in four months.” 

I was wrong, he said. I was foolish, he said. I was caught, he didn’t say. 

“I am deeply sorry for my irresponsible and selfish behaviour I engaged in.” 

To these ears, it came out thusly: “I am deeply sorry for shagging a string of bar hostesses and porn starlets and bimbos, most of whom – did you notice? – were big-haired blondes with cantilevered boobs and not a one black like me, or even half-Asian like me. I’m really regretful that so many, at least the dozen you’ve all heard about (wink, wink) weren’t able to keep their mouths shut after rubbing up against my putter. And I’m sorry to the point of semi-disclosure that my activities have cost multi-millions in endorsements lost, though I’m still the richest quasi-athlete (this is golf, after all) on the planet, just don’t for a minute suggest I’m being vengeful by staging this non-press conference on the very day of a tournament scheduled by my first-to-bail sponsor. 

“This is merely a coincidence because, while I’ve been out of that ridiculous sex addiction rehab hangout for a while, this was the only open space on my agenda to formally show my face before a hand-selected group of my very bestest buddies on the sports media planet, and by the way I would like to thank them for being so complicit in my phony image and never writing or telecasting what they’ve known all along. 

“Indeed, excuse me while I give some of them a hug, but first I have to kiss my mom, who taught me everything I know about Buddhism, most of which, of course, I’ve forgotten or ignored because following those articles of self-discipline – exercising restraint and stuff – is hard for a famous person. 

“See, trouble found me. Plus, if I were being honest, which I’m not, I’d remind everyone again that filthy rich and phenomenally exceptional athletes occupy a special place in the moral firmament – and the VIP lounges, where it’s pretty much anything goes. So what’s a handsome and rich and secretly (if not so secretly) sexual adventurer supposed to do – say thanks, but no thanks, I’m married with children and if The War Department (my wife Elin) learns about this, maybe by checking my voice mail and BlackBerry, she might threaten divorce and get some big-brain lawyer to draw up a new post-nup agreement. 

“But don’t you people go blaming Elin for any of this. The woman is a saint and I am really, really still in love with her and really, really sexually attracted to her, no matter what any of those leg-overs might have told media slimeballs. She never hit me with a golf club that Thanksgiving night before I totalled my Escalade. And I’ve never hit her either. ‘There has never been an episode of domestic violence in our marriage, ever. Elin has shown enormous grace and poise throughout this ordeal. Elin deserves praise, not blame.’ 

“The rest of you, however, and especially those aggressive paparazzi, should be disembowelled. Shame on you for chasing my kids and my mom, even stalking my 2 1/2-year old daughter at her nursery school. Can you see the smoke coming out of my ears? Hoo-boy, I’m angry. What do you mean this was to be expected as a part of the fame package when my infidelity is Page One all over the planet and I’ve gone into hiding. “Sorry, where was I? Oh yes, apologizing to my sponsors and my employees and all the kids who looked up to me as a role model, which was how my dad groomed me since I was 2 years old and swinging clubs with Bob Hope, who’s still dead. And have I mentioned the scholarships that I fund, the one with my dad’s name on it because he was my hero but he’s dead, too, and, see, I have issues. But I still am a nice guy under all those layers of pretence. ‘Character and decency are what really count.’ 

“But let’s get down to the short strokes now. I will get out on the golf circuit again, maybe later this year, at which juncture fans will start watching the sport again. I will save golf from, uh, myself. 

“Now, however, I must return to rehab seclusion and listen obediently to a whole bunch of other guys talking about all the nookie they’ve had, which makes me kind of wistful and, well, horny.”

PASSING REMARKS

 

NEW YORK–Communication and branding experts found Tiger Woods to be largely honest, contrite and sincere in his internationally televised remarks Friday.
 

They liked him taking ownership of his problems and protecting and defending his wife and kids, but some wished he’d said specifically when he’d return to golf.
 

“He finally came out, apologized and showed his face,” said Laura Ries, president of Ries and Ries, an Atlanta branding firm. “That was the most important thing, just showing up. Was it a great performance? No. But had he delivered too smooth a statement he would have been accused of being too slick.”
 

Bill McGowan, image consultant for Clarity Media Group, was less effusive. “Today should have been the complete and total purging, and I think by delaying facing some questions, he just extends this thing more.”
 

– Associated Press

Growing Idea of Third Party President

Gridlock in Washington D.C. is nothing new.  Many first term presidents have seen their party loose control of congress two years after they were elected to office.  Ronald Reagan and Bill Clinton are the two most discussed presidents that faced this situation.  The system seems more broken than ever to me.  Now many in government and at least one commentator are seeing the same conditions too.

This is the text from Meet the Press with commentator David Brooks on  February 14, 2010

MR. GREGORY:  Thirty, 30–David Brooks, 30 seconds, the outlook.

MR. BROOKS:  Well, it’s going to be a good year for Republicans.  I’m actually beginning to think, for the first time in my life, there’s a prospect for a third party at some point in the future.  I just don’t see how we get out of the fiscal hole if Republicans are not willing to raise taxes, Democrats not willing to cut spending.  I just don’t see how we get out of that, and that is the predicate.  For the first time in my life I’ve thought maybe somebody could run a third party for president, not for Congress this year.

MR. GREGORY:  Modern day Ross Perot.

MR. BROOKS:  Hopefully a little saner, but, yeah.

George Stephanopoulos of ABC reported today that Senator Evan Bayh, after announcing his decision not to run for re-election, indicated to him he thought the nation may be ready for a third party candidate for president.

The Tea Party group is not yet an organized political party but that could change if Tea Party Nation leaders were to start organizing themselves in that direction.  Sarah Palin would be their obvious candidate for president.  Isn’t she too divisive?

Could “blue dog” Democrats and “moderate” Republicans come together as a new third party?  There have been many political parties but after John Adams only Democrats, Whigs, and Republicans won the office.  George Washington and John Adams were Federalists which was a party that stood for the creation of the United States as a free and separate nation.  Every revolutionary was Federalist.

In Team of Rivals, author Doris Kearns Goodwin describes the Know Nothing Party (feared the immigration of immigrants from Germany) and the Whig Party (supported new industry and the encouragement of trade and infrastructure improvements).

Unfortunately the United States has not been a fertile ground for new political parties.

Olympics and More from Canada

There are only 33 million Canadians.  That number is about the same as California.  However, Canada is a very well educated and motivated population.  They have provided the United States with many of its leading citizens in business, politics, and entertainment.

Look at this list

Jennifer Granholm Governor of Michigan
   
Mortimer Zukerman the real estate tycoon and publisher of New York’s Daily News and U.S. News and World Report
   
Peter Jennings (July 29, 1938 – August 7, 2005) was the anchor and senior editor of ABC‘s “World News Tonight,” where he established a reputation for independence.
   
Morley Safer has been on the news program “60 Minutes” since 1970
   
Alex Trebek Host of Jeopardy quiz television show since 1984
   
Jim Carrey This famous Canadian actor has starred in tons of comedies including Bruce Almighty, The Truman Show, Man on the Moon, and many more
   
Michael J. Fox Originally a supporting actor on the sitcom Family Ties, he starred in Back to the Future, Teen Wolf, and many more popular films
   
Mike Myers once an SNL cast member. He has since starred in the Austin Powers series as well as Wayne’s World and several other famous comedies
   
Pamela Anderson This blonde bombshell has been a model and  actress.  Most famous role was on Baywatch
   
Lorne Greene actor; star of television show “Bonanza”
   
Art Linkletter TV personality; co-host of “Kids Say the Darndest Things”
   
Ali Velshi CNN’s Chief Business Correspondent

Many more famous people supplied by University of Toronto professor Jeffrey S. Rosenthal                   http://www.probability.ca/jeff/canadians.html